The Island Agency
26 Main Street
Stonington, ME 04681
Phone: (207)367-2550

About The Island Agency

Photo by Matthew Baron
We'll market your home, not just sell it. We will creatively and strategically market your property and manage the transaction every step of the way.

The Island Agency is a full service Real Estate Company offering brokerage to buyers and sellers of coastal Maine real estate. We specialize in Deer Isle and Stonington properties but offer real estate services for all of the local communities including Sedgwick, Brooklin, Brooksville, Penobscot, Blue Hill and Isle Au Haut.

As one of Downeast Maine's newest real estate companies, The Island Agency brings a fresh approach to buying and selling real estate. Our approach is based on service, responsiveness, respect and dedication to our buyers and sellers.

Although we may be a new company, The Island Agency is staffed by seasoned real estate professionals with years of experience and a deep knowledge and appreciation of the communities that we serve. We specialize in a small market area from Blue Hill to Stonington, enabling us to know the real estate market inside and out and we're able to share this expertise with our clients.

If coastal Maine is where you want to be or need to sell, contact The Island Agency.

Meet Our Team…

Morgan J. Eaton

Designated Broker/Owner

Morgan is the Owner and Designated Broker of The Island Agency in Stonington, offering Real Estate and Vacation Rental Services. Licensed since 2003, Morgan has a deep and diverse understanding of real estate marketing, property searches and smoothly completing transactions for her buyers and sellers.

As a native of Deer Isle and now a resident of Stonington, Morgan has an enthusiasm for the way of life in Maine. Her familiarity with the local market allows her a unique perspective and first-hand ability to convey the merits of the area. Morgan enjoys getting to know her clients and the excitement of finding the best property to meet their needs.

Outside of real estate and rental world, Morgan’s interests include; boating, paddle boarding, spending time with family and friends, dining out, and pickleball!

Contact Morgan to get acquainted with the real estate market and the community.

(207) 367-2550 office
(207) 610-3612 mobile
(207) 367-2835 home

Christina Hardy-Carter

Rental Manager / Associate Broker

Born and raised on the rocky Maine coast, Vacation Rental Manager and Associate Broker, Christina Hardy-Carter has a genuine love and enthusiasm for the Deer Isle – Stonington area. A graduate of Deer Isle – Stonington High School and a student of the University of Maine at Augusta Business program, Christina knows business and the local community.

Christina is funny, hard-working and efficient. Having worked locally doing various jobs from seafood processing to the service industry, she is well-informed about the area and truly appreciates the coastal lifestyle. Christina has been a part of The Island Agency’s team since they opened in 2011.

Christina lives in Stonington with her husband Shawn, and their two children; Elena and Leland. She enjoys spending time with her family, taking photographs, hiking and adventuring in her extra time.

(207) 367-2550 office
(207) 610-3715 mobile

Rhonda Mitchell

Associate Broker

Rhonda is an Associate Broker at The Island Agency and has nearly 20 years of experience in the Real Estate industry. This includes many years as a legal secretary in a real estate law firm, real estate office manager, real estate agent, and co-owner of Rocky Shore Rentals, LLC. Rhonda is a native of Deer Isle and has a great appreciation for what the peace and tranquility of island life can offer. Whether Rhonda’s involvement in a real estate transaction has been as a legal secretary, agent or office manager, her favorite part of every closing is having the opportunity to shake the hand of a buyer who has just purchased their dream property (or the hand of a seller who is happy to have closed the deal) and offer a sincere “congratulations.”

Rhonda resides in Deer Isle with her husband Corliss, and has two grown sons, Andy and Matt. When not at the office or showing properties, Rhonda enjoys spending time with family, friends and her two dogs, Harvey and Ebby. She enjoys hiking, walking on the beach and long road trips.

Stop by The Island Agency or give Rhonda a call today to see what her real estate expertise can offer you as a buyer or seller.

(207) 367-2550 office
(207) 460-2012 mobile
(207) 348-9347 home

Cindi Eaton

Associate Broker

Cindi Eaton is an Associate Broker who has been at The Island Agency since 2015. Cindi attended our local high school, and graduated from the University of Maine with a Bachelor of Science in Chemical Engineering. She worked for International Paper as a Production Engineer, and for Verso Paper as a Senior Environmental Engineer and water treatment supervisor. She also taught Chemistry and Physics at Ellsworth High School and Deer Isle – Stonington High School.

Cindi has volunteered and served as a board member for various community organizations, primarily focused on education, such as Project Launch, Seamark Community Arts, and Ready by 21. She lives on island with her husband Kevin, and their daughter Charlotte. They enjoy the outdoors and spend much of their free time boating, hiking, gardening and traveling.

Call, stop in or email Cindi to get acquainted with the local real estate market and the area.

(207) 367-2550 office
(207) 460-1002 mobile

Allen Cole

Associate Broker

Allen has worked in the merchant marine (Maine Maritime Academy) as well as both a middle school teacher and principal (Masters UMaine Ed Leadership) in local schools. He has been with The Island Agency for the past three years, first as a Sales Agent and now as an Associate Broker.

Allen volunteers as a mentor with Hancock County Restorative Justice and is a member of the Hancock County Community Reparations Board.

Allen resides in Sedgwick with his wife Charlene. When not working, Allen and Charlene enjoy spending time with their (currently) thirteen grandchildren. He also enjoys attending local sporting events, cooking, landscaping in his yard, hiking and canoeing on the Salt Pond.

His greatest satisfaction with The Island Agency has been in matching prospective buyers with their dream home. For anyone considering buying or selling in the Blue Hill Peninsula area, don’t hesitate to reach out to Allen for friendly and knowledgeable service!

(207) 367-2550 office
(207) 374-5296 mobile

Tonyia Peasley

Sales Agent

Born into a commercial fishing family, Tonyia grew up on Deer Isle. She now calls Brooksville home, where she and her husband Frank are raising two daughters; Hannah and Sophie.

A natural entrepreneur, Tonyia has worked alongside Frank in several business ventures. Currently, she heads up marketing, sales and customer relations for Little Island Oyster Co., their family oyster farm based on the Bagaduce River. A result of hard work and determination, Little Island Oysters are served nationwide and enjoy popularity with oyster lovers. Not surprisingly, Tonyia’s favorite part of oyster farming is quality control – which requires a taste testing of market size oysters.

Tonyia’s interest in real estate was spurred many years ago, as the couple acquired income properties on the Blue Hill Peninsula. Renovating and then creating a customer base for these properties, while at times challenging, was hugely rewarding. Tonyia soon found she had the knack for creating spaces guests enjoy season after season. Hosting folks from away is a pleasure for Tonyia as she enjoys sharing her extensive knowledge and true appreciation of our local areas.

When time allows, Tonyia loves spending time at “The Crow’s Nest”, their family camp on the Bagaduce River. She also enjoys dabbling in ceramics, reading a good historical fiction and checking out the local art scene. She also serves as a trustee for the Brooksville Education Foundation, a task she greatly enjoys. Above all else, Tonyia loves cheering on her daughter’s sports teams.

Tonyia’s enthusiasm, work ethic, and customer service skills will contribute well to her endeavor as a Sales Agent with The Island Agency. She has strong ties to local communities and enjoys sharing her local knowledge. If you are considering buying or selling real estate on the Blue Hill Peninsula, Tonyia would love to talk with you!

(207) 367-2550 office
(207) 460-7269 mobile

Listing data is derived in whole or in part from the Maine IDX and is for consumers' personal, non-commercial use only. Dimensions are approximate and not guaranteed. All data should be independently verified.

The Island Agency participates in MREIS' Maine Internet Data Exchange (Maine IDX) program, allowing us to display other Maine IDX Participants' Listings. We have chosen, however, to limit the Listings shown on this page to only those Listings meeting the following criteria: properties within our service area.

© 2020 Maine Real Estate Information System, Inc. All Rights Reserved.